Sweet and salty treats for an indulgent feast. Assorted chocolates, candies, and cookies. Cheddar popcorn, potato skins, and Goldfish crackers. Plush toys, bubbles, and a kick ball for entertainment. Pumpkin Peeps, cotton candy, and lollipop. Butterfinger is a candy bar created in 1923 in Chicago, Illinois by Otto Schnering, which currently is manufactured by Nestlé.